How Much Does Insurance for an LLC Actually Cost? Top 5 LLC Insurance Companies 2023


How Much Does Insurance for an LLC Actually Cost? Top 5 LLC Insurance Companies 2023

Table of Contents

Do you know what happens if your business doesn't have insurance? While paying for insurance you don't end up using is never fun, it's something you don't want to be without if an unfortunate situation arises.

Setting up a new business requires you to be diligent about specific things like filing the right paperwork with the right people and perhaps obtaining permits or licenses. And obtaining insurance for LLC operations is right up there on the list.

What Is Business Insurance for an LLC?

Business insurance for an LLC provides protection from liability claims such as property damage or bodily injury that are caused by your business, your employees, or even the products you sell (if you sell products).

If you have employees, most states require that you pay into workers' compensation insurance, which is a form of business insurance that protects your company from being financially liable for accidents your employees may have while on the job.

If you've ever claimed "workers' comp," then you may be familiar with this insurance and how it works. LLCs pay premiums for their employees to maintain coverage in the event that an incident occurs, but this isn't automatic when you form an LLC. It's also not the only type of business insurance you may need.

common types of business insurance

How Much Does Insurance for LLCs Cost?

Most companies that provide insurance for LLCs don't list prices publicly and instead require you to submit your information to receive a detailed price quote. Naturally, this can make it difficult to get an idea of what your premiums might look like for the various insurance options, so we've made it easy.

According to The Hartford, here are the average costs of small business insurance that most business owners paid for different types of coverage:

  • General liability insurance average monthly premium: $88
  • Business owner's policy average monthly premium: $261
  • Worker's compensation average monthly premium: $70

Top 5 Insurance Companies for LLCs

The Hartford

Founded in 1810, The Hartford is rated the best and second largest provider of worker's compensation coverage.
Coverage Limits
Up to $2,000,000
An average of $1,057/year
Add Ons
Business property insurance, data breach, professional liability and more

State Farm

Started in 1922, State Farm is currently rated as the best overall insurance provider for small businesses due to its extensive knowledge, top-tier customer service and customizable insurance products.
Coverage Limits
Increments of $1,000,000
Not listed
Add Ons
Commercial auto, workers’ compensation and surety and fidelity bonds


Started in 1901, Hiscox has expanded to do business in 14 countries and 50 states (including DC but not Alaska). They specialize in offering tailored options with fast quotes and claims processes.
Coverage Limits
Up to $2,000,000
From approx. $350 per year
Add Ons
Professional liability, cyber security, short-term liability, medical malpractice and more


Founded in 1925, Nationwide boasts 14 different industry specialties and has been granted an A++ Superior rating from AM Best for its financial stability. They are highly rated for general liability insurance products.
Coverage Limits
Not listed
Not listed
Add Ons
Umbrella insurance, personal liability, commercial property, commercial auto and more


Started in 1853, Travelers boasts more than 25 industry specializations and offers a full suite of insurance products for businesses of varying sizes. They have created a strong name in the commercial property insurance space.
Coverage Limits
Up to $5,000,000
Not listed
Add Ons
Commercial auto & trucking, cyber security, surety bonds, small business owners' policy and more

Incfile and The Hartford: Be Better Insured

Our partnership with The Hartford makes it easier for small businesses to get the best insurance in any industry. As one of the most reliable insurance companies in the world, The Hartford's various insurance options, including worker's compensation, auto insurance, data breach, general liability, and more, can make understanding your small business insurance needs a breeze.

Just fill out a quick online form and get your insurance quote in a matter of minutes. This "Insurance Capital of the World" has served over a million small businesses across industries, so it's no wonder why they have the best insurance policies your business can benefit from. 

Tips From the Experts: How to Shop for Business Insurance for LLC

If you need business insurance for LLC protection, you might be wondering what to look for. Are all companies the same? What about the different coverages? Here's what the experts say to look for when doing your initial research:

1. Understand Your Options (And the Various Types Available)

General liability insurance is the main type of business insurance, and it covers lawsuits that result from third-party injuries, property damage, defamation, and copyright infringement.

Other types of insurance for LLCs include commercial property insurance (covers lost, stolen, or damaged property), business interruption insurance (covers operating costs if you are forced to halt operations due to weather or other similar events), professional liability insurance (covers accidental mistakes or omissions by professional service providers), and many others that may be relevant depending on the type of business you operate.

2. Be Aware of Your Legal Obligations

In many cases, your business activities may dictate whether you need specific insurance in order to meet legal requirements.

If you rent office space, the building owner may require you to hold a valid general liability policy to cover any potential claims.

As mentioned above, if your business has employees, you'll need to have worker's compensation coverage. Be sure to check requirements in your state when conducting research for your business.

3. Always Work With Reputable, Highly Rated Providers

Business insurance for LLCs is one area where you don't want to skimp to save on cost. Consider your deductible amounts, weigh the risk associated with your business activities, and always overestimate your needs.

Reputable providers will be happy to work with you to determine what these needs are, and in this case, you definitely get what you pay for. In the event that an incident occurs, you'll be happy you went with the best of the best.

Choosing the Right Provider for Your Business Needs

Choosing an insurance company is often a gut feeling — if you've considered your options, been honest about your risk and coverage needs, and are willing to pay for reputation and ease of filing claims, it's likely that you can narrow your search to one or two providers. Go with the one that checks off all of your boxes, and feel confident in knowing that your business is protected in case of a negative event.

And be sure to notify your insurance company if you make any significant or pertinent changes to your business, or you might not have proper protection.

If you haven't yet incorporated your business and are looking at insurance as a sole proprietor, now may be the time to form an LLC with Incfile. It's fast and simple, and you can get started today with a $0 LLC (state fees apply).

Paper List

Like What You're Reading?

Get fresh monthly tips to start & grow your LLC.

Related Articles

  • 2023 Tax Deduction Cheat Sheet (Plus Key Tax Workarounds)
  • 15 Cheapest States to Form an LLC in the U.S.
  • Get an LLC for Free: A Step-by-Step Guide
  • Choosing an Amazon Seller Business Type: LLC vs. Sole Proprietorship
  • How to Transfer Your LLC to Another State
  • How Do You Obtain Free Business Address for Your LLC?
  • How to Write a Business Plan (With Template)
  • Can a Minor Own a Business?
  • 15 Items You Can Easily Flip for $100-$5,000 in Profit a Month
  • Should I Start an LLC for My Side Hustle?
  • 5 Virtual Address Services for Your Small Business
  • Need a Physical Address for Your Business?
  • 7 Home Business Ideas That Double as Tax Write-Offs
  • A Giant List of Self-Employment Ideas
  • How to File a DBA in Texas
  • Are Non-U.S. Residents Allowed to Own a Corporation or LLC?
  • Applying for Funding for Your Business? Here's Why Incfile's Fresh Start Grant Is What You Need
  • Getting a Virtual Address for Your Texas LLC
  • Our Business Names Are Too Similar, But I Am Already Established. What Can I Do Legally to Force a Name Change?
  • Can You Add a DBA to Your LLC on Your Own?